Picture the holiday ad you have seen a thousand times. Snow that has never touched Los Angeles. A family of five in coordinated sweaters. A golden retriever. A countdown clock in the corner screaming 40% OFF, ENDS TONIGHT, which it also screamed last Tuesday and will scream again next Friday.
Now picture who is actually holding the money this year.
For the first time in the 41 years Deloitte has run its holiday survey, Gen Z and millennials are expected to make up half of all holiday spending. Not a growing slice. Not an emerging segment you get to put in a “future of” slide. Half. Marketing Dive laid it out on November 17, and the number should have rattled every brand still briefing creative like the primary shopper is a suburban mom with a coupon binder.
The rest of the Deloitte picture is just as pointed. The average household expects to spend $1,654 this season, up 4% from $1,595 last year, and 79% of shoppers expect higher prices. So the money is there, the anxiety is there, and the shopper holding both is under 45 and has been lied to by a countdown clock more times than they can count.
Which brings us to the number that should end the discount theater for good: only 32% of shoppers completely or mostly trust retailers to offer a fair price.
Thirty-two percent. Two out of three people looking at your Black Friday banner assume it is some flavor of bullshit. The strikethrough price, the fake scarcity, the sale that has been “ending soon” since Halloween. They see the mechanics. They grew up inside the mechanics. They can smell a manufactured deadline from across a parking lot.
And yet most holiday creative still leads with the mechanics, because it is easy to brief, easy to measure and easy to defend in a quarterly review. Percent off is a number. Trust is a feeling, and feelings do not fit neatly in a media plan.
Here is what the younger half of the holiday actually wants, according to Deloitte’s own read. Brian McCarthy, a principal in Deloitte’s strategy and analytics practice, told Marketing Dive that younger shoppers want a bit more guidance, personalization and convenience. Wish lists. Personalized gifts. Faster delivery. In other words: help me, know me, don’t waste my time.
That is not a discount brief. That is a relationship brief.
The creator side of the business is seeing the same shift. Becky Owen, CMO of Billion Dollar Boy Group, told Marketing Dive that holiday creator activations are getting more psychology-driven, and that the era of the loudest brand winning is fading. Volume used to be the strategy. Now volume just reads as desperation with a bigger media budget.
The brands getting it right this season are not hiding the ball. Urban Outfitters built its holiday push around a finding that the majority of Gen Z plans to self-gift, and partnered with DoorDash on an immersive gifting suite. That is a brand that read the actual behavior of its customer and built creative that meets it, rather than pretending everyone is buying for a grandma in Ohio. JCPenney cast a local barber in Crown Point, Indiana, styling three holiday looks for $168 total. A real guy, a real town, a real number. The price is there, but it is wrapped in a person you believe.
Compare that to the brand that took a beating this season for a $148 advent calendar that turned out to be stuffed with hair ties and bobby pins. Skims drew a wave of criticism for it, and the lesson is not that premium prices are wrong. It is that this audience will publicly audit the gap between what you charge and what you deliver, and the audit happens in the comments, in real time, with screenshots.
Then there is the AI layer, and it cuts the opposite way from what most brands assume. Gartner found that more than a third of consumers are very or extremely willing to use generative AI tools for holiday shopping. But the shoppers who use AI for gift inspiration are not shortcutting the journey. They consult an average of 4.48 additional sources, against 3.24 for people who do not use AI. The AI shopper is the research shopper. They are checking you. Then checking you again.
Gartner’s own analyst, Emily Weiss, framed it the way most brands do not want to hear it: AI is not streamlining the shopping journey, it is adding another layer to it. Her advice was unglamorous and correct. Make yourself discoverable, and keep your product availability and shipping information current. Translation: the assistant your customer asks is going to compare your claims against everyone else’s, and anything inflated gets caught in the cross-check.
So the young, digitally fluent, price-skeptical shopper who now controls half the season is also running more due diligence on you than any shopper in history. Discount theater does not survive that much scrutiny. Trust does.
Now for the turn, because the obvious counter is sitting right there.
Deloitte classifies 38% of shoppers as value seekers, people running five or more cost-saving behaviors, and they are expected to spend 12% more than last year. So discounts work, right? Price is king, the audience is broke, run the promo.
Wrong read. McCarthy’s line on this is the most useful sentence in the whole report: “I think of value seeking as another way of saying engaged shoppers.” Value seekers are not bargain zombies clicking on anything with a red tag. They are the most engaged, most attentive, most comparison-happy shoppers you have. They are reading the fine print. They know what the item cost in September. They are exactly the people a fake markdown insults, and exactly the people a transparent, well-told reason to buy will convert.
A value seeker does not want a bigger number on a banner. They want a reason to believe the number on the banner.
That changes the creative job. Stop briefing “urgency.” Start briefing proof. Show the product doing the thing. Put a real person in it, in a real place, saying what it actually costs and why. Let the barber in Indiana sell the look. Let the founder explain why the price did not move. Let the comments in, because this audience will find them anyway.
Out here in LA, you can see the gap on any commercial strip. The shop with a permanent “Going Out of Business” banner has been going out of business for six years, and everyone in the neighborhood knows it. Meanwhile the little spot where the owner knows your name and tells you straight that the cheaper one is fine has a line out the door on a Saturday. Same block. Same customers. Completely different level of trust.
Big brands are running the same experiment at national scale, and most of them are the banner.
The irony is that this generation is not cheap. They are spending more, not less. They are buying experiences, gifting themselves, paying for convenience, and showing up for brands that make them feel seen. What they will not do is pretend your manufactured deadline is real. They have been marketed to since birth. They know the trick. Doing the trick louder is not a strategy.
Half the holiday belongs to people who don’t trust your price tag.
Your creative can either earn that trust or keep yelling at their parents.